Skip to main content

Table 7 Comparison of this study’s ESD with other national and international studies

From: Estimation of dose and cancer risk to newborn from chest X-ray in South-South Nigeria: a call for protocol optimization

 

Mean (mGy)

Q3 (mGy)

Minimum (mGy)

Maximum (mGy)

Age range

Mode of measurement

Detector

This studya

1.19

1.56

0.32

2.01

≤ 30 days

Direct

TLD

ACR [15]a,b

0.12/0.06

0–1 years

Directd

TLD

Brazil [23]

0.07/0.05

 

0.06/0.04

0.09/0.08

0–1 year

Direct

CaSO4:Dy/TLD

Iran [24]a

0.076

0.07

< 1 year

Direct

TLD

Nigeria [25]c

0.64/0.07/1.1

0–1 year

Direct

TLD

Turkey [26]

0.067/0.07

6–112 days

Direct/indirect

TLD/tube output

Ethiopia [27]

1.82

1.37

0.97

2.34

0–1 year

Indirect

Tube output

Kuwait [28]b

0.074

< 1 year

Indirect

Tube output

Finland [29]

0.06

0.01

0.27

0 year

Indirect

Tube output

EC [30]

0.08

0 year

Indirect

Tube output

UNSCEAR [31]

0.041

0–1 year

Indirect

Tube output

UK [32]

0.06

0.07

0.03

0.09

0 year

Indirect

Tube output

Nigeria [33]

0.11

0–1 year

Indirect

DoseCal

Sudan [34]

0.057

 

0.031

0.368

0– < 1 year

Indirect

DoseCal

  1. aGrid system was used
  2. bNo grid system was used
  3. cComparison was made with 3 hospitals
  4. dPhantom was used, EC European Commission