Skip to main content

Table 2 Distribution of patients according to clinical severity and HRCT characteristics with estimation of proportionate severity factor

From: COVID-19 clinico-radiological mismatch: a proposal for a novel combined morphologic/volumetric CT severity score with blinded validation

Clinical severity (respiratory status):

Group (1) mild

Group (2) border line severity

Group (3) severe–critical

Estimation of “total

severity factor" and approximated score points

-

-

-

O2 saturation and requirements:

Dyspnea:

Respiratory rate (RR):

95–100%,

Absent or mild (type I)

RR < 30/min

93–94% (+) one of:

High grade (type II or III)

RR ≥ 30/min

< 93% (O2 support or ventilation)

High grade (type II or III)

RR ≥ 30/min

-

Total number (TN) and percentage (379)

298 (79%)

57 (15%)

24 (6%)

HRCT characteristics:

N

%

a Severity

ratio

N

%

Severity

ratio

N

%

Severity

ratio

Total

Points

Volumetric analysis:

[S1]

0–15% of lung volume is involved:

Total:

271 (72%)

271

100%

a 1.3

Negative

Negative

1.3

1

[S2]

15–25% of lung volume is involved:

Total:

51 (13%)

27

53%

0.7

24

47%

3.1

Negative

3.8

4

[S3]

25–50% of lung volume is involved:

Total:

49 (13%)

Negative

33

67%

4.5

16

33%

5.5

10

10

[S4]

> 50% of lung volume is involved:

Total:

8 (2%)

Negative

Negative

8

100%

16.7

16.7

17

Morphologic pattern:

[M1]

Pure GGO:

Total:

154 (41%)

150

97%

1.2

4

3%

0.2

Negative

1.4

1

[M2]

GGOs with “Atoll sign”:

Total:

50 (13%)

46

92%

1.2

4

8%

0.5

Negative

1.7

2

[M3]

GGOs mixed with consolidations:

Total:

80 (21%)

70

87%

1.1

10

13%

0.9

Negative

2

2

[M4]

Homogeneous consolidations or “curvilinear” consolidations:

Total:

29 (8%)

15

52%

0.7

14

48%

3.2

Negative

3.9

4

[M5]

GGOs with “air bubble sign”:

Total:

7 (2%)

3

43%

0.5

3

43%

2.9

1

14%

2.3

5.8

6

[M6]

GGOs with early secondary fibrosis and architectural distortion:

Total:

26 (7%)

7

27%

0.3

11

42%

2.8

8

31%

5.2

8.3

8

[M7]

Patchy GGOs with smooth septal thickening “focal crazy-paving” pattern:

Total:

26 (7%)

7

27%

0.3

11

42%

2.8

8

31%

5.2

8.3

8

             

Maximum (SF = 25)

[M8]

It refers to diffuse alveolar damage pattern (DAD);

- By definition, it is diffused (> 50%) of lung volume involvement [S4]

- By definition, it represents mixed GGOs with “crazy-paving pattern” and “air bubble sign.”

 

Total:

7 (2%)

Negative

Negative

7 (100%)

 
  1. a Severity ratio = prevalence rate of HRCT finding among the total number of each patients’ group/prevalence rate of each patients’ group among total sample size; example 100%/79% = 1.3