CT arthrography for demonstration of various articular injuries in post-sprained ankle pain
Egyptian Journal of Radiology and Nuclear Medicine volume 50, Article number: 97 (2019)
Post-sprained ankles may sustain ligamentous tear, chondral defect, or osteochondral lesions (OCL). Being widely available and does not depend on high-end machine, the aim of this study was to assess the value of high resolution multi-detector CT arthrography (CTA) in detection of various ligamentous tears, chondral defects, and osteochondral lesions in case of sprain-related persistent ankle pain.
There were 34 (68%) cases of ligamentous injury, most of which had single ligament affection whereas some cases demonstrated multi-ligamentous injury, and the total number of individual injured ligaments was 42 ligaments. There were 36 cases (72%) which had either chondral or osteochondral defects; the total number of OCL was 21 lesions and the total number of segmental cartilage defects was 20.
This study emphasized the diagnostic importance of multi-detector CTA in sprain-related ankle pain. In persistent post-sprained ankle pain, multi-detector CTA is a helpful imaging modality which could be utilized for detection of OCL, chondral defects, and various ligamentous tears.
Ankle sprain is one of the most common lower extremity injuries; it is responsible for about 10% of emergency room visits and up to 21% of sports-related injuries. Lateral sprain is the commonest, accounting for about 85% of all ankle sprains. Post-sprained ankles may sustain one or more intra-articular injuries as ligamentous tear, chondral defect, and osteochondral lesions (OCL) [1,2,3,4].
Non-arthrographic imaging tools including ultrasonography and conventional MRI can be utilized for assessment of ligamentous injuries; however, proper characterization of OCL needs arthrographic-based techniques. CT arthrography (CTA) is a helpful imaging tool which could be utilized in different joints especially the small ones. The advances in CT technologies in last years, principally the multi-channel detector arrays scanners, bring the CTA into the forefront in joint imaging beside the MR arthrography. In the ankle, being a small joint, the imaging technique should have high spatial resolution property, and therefore, CT arthrography might be the study of choice in certain situations in the ankle such as in cartilage imaging and osteochondral lesion assessment, as the ankle has very thin cartilage layer covering its articular surfaces, with their mean ranges from 1.0 to 1.62 mm in thickness with 0.4 standard deviation [5,6,7,8,9,10].
Furthermore, CTA can be utilized to detect ligamentous injuries, as it could directly discern ligamentous discontinuity as in anterior talo-fibular ligament (ATFL), or demonstrate extra-articular passage of contrast medium, as into peroneal tendon in case of calcaneo-fibular ligament (CFL) tear .
Aim of the work
Being widely available and does not depend on high-end machine, the aim of this study was to assess the ability of high resolution multi-detector CTA in detection of various ligamentous tears, chondral defects, and osteochondral lesions in case of sprain-related persistent ankle pain.
This study was conducted during June 2017 through June 2018 after being ethically approved by our institution committee. Fifty patients, suffering from sprain-related ankle pain, were referred from orthopedic clinics, in our hospital, and underwent CT arthrography using Philips 16-detector row machine. Informed written consent was obtained from all patients prior to study.
Inclusion criteria for patients were based on (1) chronic post-sprain ankle pain lasting more than 3 months either continuously or intermittently. (2) Subacute sprain-related persistent ankle pain more than 2 weeks duration despite adequate treatment protocol. (3) Recurrent ankle sprain more than three episodes, currently presented with severe acute sprain less than 2 weeks duration.
Overlying or surrounding soft tissue infection was the only exclusion criterion.
Ultrasonographic-guided contrast injection
Ultrasonographic study was the aiding imaging tool, using which the injection of the articular contrast martial was performed. It was done using Xario-200 Toshiba machine with multi-frequency linear array transducer (selected frequency 12 MHz). The patients were examined while in supine position with the ankle on the examination table. Anterior joint recess evaluation was done for the presence of joint effusion in sagittal and lateral parasagittal planes. Aspiration of any joint effusion was done under careful sterile technique prior to contrast injection.
The injected contrast was non-ionic iodinated contrast medium (Ioversol; Optiray® 350); the contrast medium was diluted 1:1 with lidocaine HCL 1%. The utilized needle was 25-gauge and 1.5 in. length. The ultrasound transducer was placed longitudinally on the antero-medial ankle between the extensor halluces longus and the tibialis anterior tendon, in order to avoid injury of the dorsalis pedis artery; the entry point was 1–2 cm distal to joint line with 30o upwards angulation; when the tip of the needle was imaged in the tibio-talar interval, about 8–12 cc of diluted contrast was injected; and the injection was continued until firm resistance to ensure adequate joint distension [12, 13].
The patient was scanned in “supine” position using high resolution bone algorithm, thin beam collimation (0.6 mm), small FOV (~ 140 mm), and exposure parameters of 120 kV and 200 mAs.
Image processing and analysis
True axial images were obtained through the long axis of the talus. Coronal reformatted images were obtained along the anterior talar margin. Sagittal images were obtained along the long axis of the calcaneus. Oblique axial images were obtained through the course of the anterior tibio-fibular ligaments 45o from inferior lateral to superior medial [12, 13].
Overview of the entire joint was done using the axial cuts. ATFL, CFL, deep deltoid ligament, and extra-articular passage of contrast were examined on axial plane. Syndesmotic ligaments were assessed on axial oblique images. The coronal and sagittal planes were essential planes for evaluation for chondral defects and OCL [12, 13].
OCL classification followed Berndt and Harty staging system modified by Anderson et al. The classification system indicates stage I when the focal compression of the subchondral bone with intact overlying cartilage, stage II when incomplete separation of an OCL, stage IIA means formation of subchondral cyst, stage III when complete detachment of the OCL that remain in situ, and stage IV when complete detachment of the OCL that become displaced.
The ATFL thickness was measured on all cases on true axial images, and it was measured at the thinnest portion in cases demonstrating partial tear, whereas in cases demonstrating intact ligament, it was measured at its mid-portion, cases with complete ATFL tear were not measured as this was not applicable. CFL thickness was measured at its mid-portion in all cases except when torn due to volume averaging from extra-articular contrast within the peroneal tendon sheath, the syndesmotic recess length was measured in coronal plane in all cases from the tibial plafond distally to its top [12, 13].
Results of CTA were recorded and tabulated, and the statistical analysis was done using SPSS-16; the data were represented as number and percent. Comparison between ATFL thickness in intact and partially injured cases was done using Mann-Whitney test for non-parametric data. Correlation analysis between pathologic ankle changes and the type of presenting pain was done and Spearman correlation coefficient (r) was assessed. P value < 0.05 was considered significant.
There were 23 males and 27 females. The mean age of male patients was 30.83 + 6.56 years (range 17–44 years), whereas the mean age of female patients was 37.3 + 9.18 years (range 22–50 years).
The most common onset of ankle pain in the study was the chronic onset (29 cases 58%) and then subacute onset (18 cases 36%), the acute onset was present in only three cases, all of which have previous sprain. Recurrent sprain were present in (11 cases 22%).
Diffuse ankle pain was the most common presentation (20 cases 40%), followed by lateral ankle pain (18 cases 36%), and then medial ankle pain (12 cases 24%).
The most common type of ankle sprain during presentation was the lateral sprain which was present in 38 cases, whereas 12 cases had medial ankle sprain.
MDCT arthrographic findings
There were 34 (68%) cases had ligamentous injury on CT arthrography, most of which had single ligament affection whereas some cases demonstrated multi-ligamentous injury. The total number of individual injured ligaments was 42 ligaments (Table 1).
The ATFL thickness in cases had an intact ligament and in cases which had partial injury are demonstrated in Table 2, and the lower limit of normal was 1.1 mm, whereas in partial injury was 0.3 mm; however, there was a statistically insignificant difference. Mean CFL thickness and syndesmotic recess length are presented in Table 2.
There were 36 cases (72%) which had either chondral or osteochondral defects; 18 cases had osteochondral lesions and another 18 cases had chondral injury with intact subchondral bone plate. The total number of OCLs in our study was 22 lesions observed in 18 cases, as there were four cases with talar dome OCL had double OCLs on the medial and lateral corners of the talar dome. The total number of cartilage defects in our study was 20 lesions in 18 cases, with two cases had concurrent tibial and talar cartilage defects (Table 3, Figs. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8).
Among other arthrographic features, there was one case demonstrating cartilaginous intra-articular bodies, and 21 cases (42%) had synovial thickening.
Regarding the ultrasonographic features detected before contrast injection, there were 16 cases (32%) which had joint effusion, ten of them had synovial thickening.
Among the 34 cases that have ligamentous injury in the study, there were 11 cases complicated with ankle instability; all of them underwent operative treatment and/or ligamentous repair, and all of them were true positive cases proven in operative interventions with no false positive cases. The types of operated ligamentous tears are categorized in Table 4.
Two minor complications happened during arthrographic procedure; four patients developed vaso-vagal attack, as they were sitting rather than lying supine while performing the procedure; and five patients developed mild peri-articular swelling especially anteriorly due to mixed intra- and extra -articular contrast injection. No major complications happened (Table 5).
There was a significant reasonable positive correlation between the presence of OCL or chondral defects and chronic pain presentation, and recurrent sprain (Table 6).
For many years, conventional MRI of the ankle was the traditional imaging study used to assess for ligamentous injuries; however, there are many situations preclude the utility of MRI as in case of presence of a cardiac pacemaker, in certain types of aneurysm clips and in cochlear implant; in such cases, CT arthrography would be the excellent solution.
Multi-detector CTA can directly visualize a lot of ankle ligaments, which develop anatomically as intra-capsular structures and are normally highlighted by joint fluid. Depending on this fact, most of ankle ligaments could be readily outlined by intra-articular contrast during arthrographic studies, and this highlighting can be easily observed in CTA due to its high spatial resolution. In CTA, the high attenuation of injected contrast medium, in adequately distended joint, could surround the following ligaments: ATFL, PTFL, DDL, and syndesmotic ligaments; therefore, they will appear as hypo-attenuated structures, highlighted by high density of injected contrast, and this will not only occur along their inner contours, and also along their outer surfaces. The other ligaments (SDL and CFL) are delineated through their inner surfaces only as they are tightly applied to the joint capsule; their injuries are diagnosed by demonstrating contrast leakage beyond them into adjacent tendon sheaths (i.e., into the tibialis posterior tendon sheath in case of SDL and into the peroneal tendon sheath in case of CFL). Furthermore, CTA is a well-established imaging technique for detection of chondral defects and OCL especially in small joints. CTA of the ankle is considered superior to MR arthrography in hyaline cartilage imaging being very thin in the ankle. MR arthrography has low spatial resolution, and it is unable to separate the closely apposed tibial and talar cartilages and could not detect partial thickness chondral defect. On the other hand, the inherent high resolution of CTA permits easy depiction of the articular cartilage along each articular surface across the joint, and the articular cartilage is clearly seen by virtue of five thin alternating layers of high and low attenuations formed by hyperdense subchondral bone plate, hypodense hyaline cartilage on each side of the joint, and intervening hyperdense contrast material [14,15,16,17].
The purpose of the current study was to evaluate the diagnostic value of CTA in post-sprained ankle not only for detection of chondral defects and osteochondral lesions, which are the traditional indications for CTA, but also for detection of concurrent ligamentous tears.
Most of cases in the current study were presented with chronic or subacute ankle sprains with persistent pain, among the study cases; there were 34 (68%) which had ligamentous injury detected on CTA, with some had multiple ligament tears. To the best of authors’ knowledge, there is lack of studies concerned with the prevalence of ligamentous injuries in sprain-related ankle pain. The high percentage of ligamentous tear found in the current study could be expected particularly in the context of chronic or recurrent sprains, and in such cases, suspicion of ligamentous injury should be raised and kept in mind, as unhealed tear will be a source of persistent ankle pain and/or leads to abnormal joint motion which in turn leads to ankle instability and development of a vicious circle of recurrent sprains.
Regarding the ligamentous dimensions in the current study, there was no significant difference between partially torn ATFL and intact ones regarding their ligament thickness value (both had mean of 2-mm thickness) although the lower range value was thinner in partially torn ATFL (0.3 mm) than in intact ligament (1.1 mm). The mean thickness of normal CFL was 1.9 mm. These data are in concordance with Dimmick et al. 2009, who studied the thickness of ATFL and CFL in normal and abnormal ankles; they utilized MRI in their study and found that the mean thickness of the ATFL was 2.19 ± 0.6 mm and the CFL measured 2.13 ± 0.5 mm, with statistically insignificant difference between normal and abnormal ankles. This statistically insignificant difference between partially torn ATFL and normal ones could signify the utility of the morphologic abnormalities found in torn ligament (such as uneven thickness, bowing, or laxity) as indicators for ligament injury rather than relying on its numerical value of ligament thickness .
In this study, there were no cases with high ankle or syndesmotic sprain, all cases demonstrated intact anterior inferior tibio-fibular and posterior inferior tibio-fibular ligaments, and the mean syndesmotic recess length was 13.66 ± 3.9 mm (range 3.5–23 mm). Multiple reports studied the syndesmotic ligaments, however with no thorough documentation or clear cutoff values between normal measurement and abnormal ones. Brown et al. 2004 studied ankle syndesmotic recess by MRI; they found an average recess height of 5 mm in normal syndesmosis and of 14 mm and of 12 mm in chronic and acute syndesmosis injury respectively; these values are seemingly discordant with our results but, this would be attributed to large standard deviation of their means. Moreover, Kim et al. 2007 studied syndesmotic ankle injuries using contrast-enhanced MRI and measured the length of enhancing syndesmotic recess, although they measured the enhanced tissue about the recess, and although they extended the height measurement distally to the talar dome, their results are partially concordant with the current study, they found that the mean height of enhancing tissue delineating the syndesmotic recess was 12.6 mm ± 5.1 in non-injured ankles whereas it was higher in injured ankle group (16.2 mm ± 3.3) with statistically significant difference. Bartonicek 2003 studied the anatomy of the tibiofibular syndesmosis and found that the expansion of contrast solution as far as 1.2 cm above the joint could not be considered an indicator of tibiofibular syndesmosis disruption or injury of the interosseous tibiofibular ligament; furthermore, he did not give cutoff value between normal and abnormal syndesmotic height measures [19,20,21].
Regarding frequency of chondral and OCL in the current study, there were 36 cases (72%) which had either chondral defect or OCL; some of which had more than one osteochondral lesions or multi-focal cartilage defect. The occurrence of such lesions in study cases could be expected especially when poor recovery from ankle sprain occurs; however, such high percentage (72%) of chondral and OCLs might be a little bit surprising, as the indication of CTA in our study was centered about post-sprained ankle pain especially the chronic one which showed a positive correlation with the presence of chondral defect/OCL. The clinical suspicion of chondral/OCL was not an indication for CTA in our study. Kirschke et al. 2016 studied the diagnostic value of CTA for evaluation of osteochondral lesions at the ankle, although the primary indication for CTA in all their cases was to visualize chondral or osteochondral defects; their results are almost in agreement with our study; and they found that 51/79 (64%) of patients had talar cartilage defects/OCL and 38/79 (48%) of patients had tibial cartilage defects/OCL. Furthermore, Kirschke 2016 considered CTA as a reference standard technique in order to compare their findings with those of MRI, and they found that MRI was able to visualize only 83.1% of cartilage defects and 63.6% of defects of the subchondral bone. In contrast, the current study did not combine CTA with MRI or MR arthrography due to some logistic reasons; it only utilized CTA, in part because of a very thin normal ankle hyaline cartilage and in part due to inherent high resolution of CT images in examining osseous injuries. The high percentage of chondral defect/OCL discovered in the study, together with their positive correlation with chronic ankle pain and with recurrent sprain, could highlight their importance; there should be a high level of expectance of their presence when chronic post-sprained ankle pain workup is initiated [7, 9, 22].
Although surgical interventions of some patients in our study allowed for assessment of positive cases, negative case assessment was not available, since operative intervention was primarily targeted to the CTA detected ligamentous tear, and the relatively little number of surgically treated cases is also a limitation. Moreover, although CTA might be considered as a reference for OCL, there was lack of ankle arthroscopy as a reference standard method, as it is not frequently performed in our institution.
In summary, this study emphasized the diagnostic importance of multi-detector CTA in sprain-related ankle pain. In conclusion, in persistent post-sprained ankle pain, multi-detector CTA is a helpful imaging modality that could be utilized for detection of OCL, chondral defects, and various ligamentous tears.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and analyzed during the study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Anterior talo-fibular ligament
Deep deltoid ligament
Medial malleolar fascial sleeve
Superficial deltoid ligament
Cerezal L, Abascal F, Garcia-Valtuille R, Canga A (2005) Ankle MR arthrography: how, why and when. Radiol Clin N Am 43:693–707
Cheung Y, Perrich KD, Gui J, Koval KJ, Goodwin DW (2009) MRI of isolated distal fibular fractures with widened medial clear space on stressed radiographs: which ligaments are interrupted? Am J Roentgenol 192(1):W7. https://doi.org/10.2214/AJR.08.1092
Kim M, Choi YS, Jeong MS, Park M, Chun TJ, Kim JS, Young KW (2017) Comprehensive assessment of ankle syndesmosis injury using 3D isotropic turbo spin-echo sequences: diagnostic performance compared with that of conventional and oblique 3-T MRI. AJR 208:827–833
Wikstrom EA, Hubbard-Turner T, McKeon PO (2013) Understanding and treating lateral ankle sprains and their consequences: a constraints-based approach. Sports Med 43(6):385–393
El-Khoury GY, Alliman KJ, Lundberg HJ, Rudert MJ, Brown TD, Saltzman CL (2004) Cartilage thickness in cadaveric ankles: measurement with double contrast multi-detector row CT arthrography versus MR imaging. Radiology 233:768–773
Shepherd DE, Seedhom BB (1999) Thickness of human articular cartilage in joints of the lower limb. Ann Rheum Dis 58:27–34
Schmid MR, Pfirrmann CW, Hodler J, Vienne P, Zanetti M (2003) Cartilage lesions in the ankle joint: comparison of MR arthrography and CT arthrography. Skelet Radiol 32:259–265
O’Loughlin PF, Heyworth BE, Kennedy JG (2010) Current concepts in the diagnosis and treatment of osteochondral lesions of the ankle. Am J Sports Med 38:392–404
Naran KN, Zoga AC (2008) Osteochondral lesions about the ankle. Radiol Clin N Am 46(6):995–1002
Kassarjian A (2012) Current concepts in MR and CT arthrography. Semin Musculoskelet Radiol 16(1):1–2
Crim J (2018) Lateral ligament injury, ankle. In: Crim J (ed) Specialty imaging. Arthrography, vol 8, 2nd edn. Elsevier, Altona, Manitoba, Canada, p 234
Crim J (2018) Basic techniques. In: Crim J (ed) Specialty imaging, arthrography, vol 1, 2nd edn. Elsevier, Altona, Manitoba, Canada, pp 2–3
Allam MF (2018) Ankle imaging: CT arthrography, In: Allam MF et.al (eds). CT arthrography of the ankle. 1st edn. Scholar’s Press, (an imprint of SIA OmniScriptum Publishing), Chisinau, Balti, Riga, Mauritius, p. 21–32
Kraniotis P, Maragkos S, Tyllianakis M, Petsas T, Karantanas AH (2012) Ankle post-traumatic osteoarthritis: a CT arthrography study in patients with bi- and trimalleolar fractures. Skelet Radiol 41(7):803–809
Delport AG, Zoga AC (2012) MR and CT arthrography of the elbow. Semin Musculoskelet Radiol 16(1):15–26
Allam MF, Elian MM, Allam AF (2018) The value of multi-detector CT arthrography of the wrist joint in evaluation of ligamentous and capsular injuries in post-traumatic pain. EJRNM 49:394–399
Crim J, Rosenberg ZS (2016) Ankle. In: Manaster BJ, Crim J (eds) Imaging anatomy. Musculoskeletal, 2nd edn. Elsevier, Canada Altona, Manitoba. Section 11, chapter 51, p 919
Dimmick S, Kennedy D, Daunt N (2009) Evaluation of thickness and appearance of anterior talofibular and calcaneofibular ligaments in normal versus abnormal ankles with MRI. J Med Imag Radiation Oncol 52:559–563
Brown KW, Morrison WE, Schwetzer ME, Parellada A, Nothnagel H (2004) MRI findings associated with distal tibiofibular syndesmosis injuries. AJR Am J Roentgenol 182:131–136
Kim S, Huh YM, Song HT, Lee SA, Lee JW, Lee JE, Chung IH, Suh JS (2007) Chronic tibiofibular syndesmosis injury of ankle: evaluation with contrast enhanced fat-suppressed 3D fast spoiled gradient-recalled acquisition in the steady state MR imaging. Radiology 242:225–235
Bartonicek J (2003) Anatomy of the tibiofibular syndesmosis and its clinical relevance. Surg Radiol Anat 25:379–386
Kirschke JS, Braun S, Baum T, Holwein C, Schaeffeler C, Imhoff AB, Rummeny EJ, Woertler K, Jungmann PM (2016) Diagnostic value of CT arthrography for evaluation of osteochondral lesions at the ankle. Biomed Res Int 3594253. https://doi.org/10.1155/2016/3594253
The study had no funding from any resource.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Medicine, Minya University, on March 5, 2017; reference number of approval FMREC1764. All cases gave written informed consent to participate in the research.
Consent for publication
All patients included in this study gave written informed consent for data publishing contained within this study.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
El-Sherif, A.M.H., Mohamed, M.A.A., El-Ameen, N.F.M. et al. CT arthrography for demonstration of various articular injuries in post-sprained ankle pain. Egypt J Radiol Nucl Med 50, 97 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1186/s43055-019-0101-0