Role of diffusion MRI in diagnosis of mediastinal lymphoma: initial assessment and response to therapy

Abstract

Background

Malignant lymphoma accounts for nearly 20% of all mediastinal neoplasms in adults and 50% in children. Hodgkin’s disease is the most common primary mediastinal lymphoma. In non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, the two most common forms of primary mediastinal lymphoma are lymphoblastic lymphoma and diffuse large B-cell lymphoma. The aim of this study is to implement diffusion MRI in the algorithm of diagnosis of mediastinal lymphoma, differentiating Hodgkin's from non-Hodgkin's lymphoma and assessment of post therapeutic response.

Results

Using Diffusion weighted magnetic resonance imaging DWI-MRI, there were statistic significant difference between ADC values in lymph nodes and mediastinal masses in Hodgkin and non-Hodgkin lymphomas. ADC range in non-treated Hodgkin lymphoma cases was 0.774 to 1.4, while ADC range in in non-treated non-Hodgkin lymphoma was 0.476 to 0.668. In this study, there was statistically significant difference of ADC values in lymphoma cases presented by mediastinal masses with and without chemotherapy.

Conclusions

Diffusion weighted magnetic resonance imaging DWI-MRI is a promising functional technique in diagnosis of Hodgkin's and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma and assessment of response to treatment with no need for special preparation, contrast injection or radiation exposure.

Background

Malignant lymphoma accounts for nearly 20% of all mediastinal neoplasms in adults and 50% in children. Hodgkin’s disease is the most common primary mediastinal lymphoma. In non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, the two most common forms of primary mediastinal lymphoma are lymphoblastic lymphoma and diffuse large B-cell lymphoma [1].

Mediastinal lymph nodes are divided into 7 zones and 14 stations as defined by the International Association for the Study of Lung Cancer (IASLC) [2, 3]. However, it can be used in lymph node classification in lymphoma [4].

New MRI techniques, such as MRI diffusion weighted imaging (DWI), may be an alternative to CT and FDG-PET/CT in diagnostic imaging protocols for malignant lymphoma [5].

Diffusion refers to the random Brownian motion of water molecules [6]. T2-weighted images are converted to diffusion weighted images by applying diffusion gradient pulses before and after the 180° radiofrequency pulse. The b value (in seconds per square millimeter) depends on and increases with amplitude, duration of application, and separation of diffusion gradient [7]. Calculation of ADC from DW-MRI is measured by performing DW-MRI with at least two diffusion weightings, or b values. The differential signal attenuation at different b values can be used to calculate the ADC [8].

In Hodgkin lymphoma the most commonly affected nodes include the prevascular, paratracheal and to less extent the hilar and subcarinal lymph nodes, while in non-Hodgkin lymphoma the most common lymph nodes involved are prevascular and paratracheal followed by the subcarinal, hilar, internal mammary, pericardial and posterior mediastinal nodes [9].

In Hodgkin lymphoma, thymic lymphoma and the involved nodes usually reveal homogeneous low signal intensity on T1-weighted images [10]. On T2-weighted MR images, they usually demonstrate homogeneous high signal intensity [11]. The mean ADC value of Hodgkin lymphomas is (1.07 ± 0.11 × 10⁻³ mm²/s) [12].

While in non-Hodgkin lymphoma, the tumors appear as a large anterior mediastinal mass in nearly all patients. Solid portions of lymphoma are hypo intense in T1-weighted images but iso intense in T2-weighted images [13]. The mean ADC value for non-Hodgkin lymphoma is (0.97 ± 0.24 × 10⁻³ mm²/s) [12].

In mediastinal lymphomas, a residual mass is common after treatment, especially in cases with a bulky initial mass and MRI provides important information in differentiation viable tumors from residual benign masses [14].

Mediastinal masses span a wide histopathological and radiological spectrum. While relatively specific imaging clues exist for certain lesions such as thyroid masses and cysts, many solid malignant and benign lesions appear remarkably similar on computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) [15].

The major differential diagnoses of anterior mediastinal solid tumours in adults include thymic epithelial tumor, germ cell tumor, lymphoma and intra-thoracic goiter [16].

Differentiating lymphoma from sarcoidosis in mediastinal and hilar lymphadenopathy can be done by detecting the ADC value of the enlarged lymph nodes, the ADC value in the lymphoma was detected to be lower than that in the sarcoidosis group [17].

The aim of this study is to implement diffusion MRI in the algorithm of diagnosis of mediastinal lymphoma and assessment of post therapeutic response.

Methods

This cross sectional study involved 32 patients diagnosed as lymphoma; 18 males and 14 females, age range 18–69 years (average of 34.375 years). The complaints varied between dyspnea, chest pain, purities, fever and loss of weight.

Cases were referred from clinical oncology department to radiology department for MRI chest with diffusion in the period from December 2018 to March 2020.

Inclusion criteria

Patient diagnosed to have mediastinal lymphoma by biopsy and histopathological analysis.

Exclusion criteria

Contraindication to MRI e.g. Patients with pace maker, cochlear implants, cerebral aneurysm clips, ocular metallic foreign body, bullets or gunshots near great vessels or vital organs.

MRI technique

The MR scanning sequences were T1W1, T2WI, T2 STIR and DWI including quantitative DWI analysis (ADC measurement). Respiratory gating has been used in all patients. MR imaging parameters are listed in Table 1.

Table 1 MR imaging parameters

Assessment of cases

Three cardiothoracic radiologists with 5 (reader 1), 10 (reader 2) and more than 25 (reader 3) years of experience, respectively, interpret the images. Disagreements among readers regarding the images were resolved by consensus after a discussion between both readers and a third chest radiologist with more than 25 years of experience (consensus decision).

A. Patient grouping

• Cases were divided into two groups according to receiving chemotherapy or not. Non treated group include 18 cases while treated group include 14 cases.

B. Image assessment

Qualitative analysis:

• MR images qualitatively analyzed by visual assessment of the different pulse sequences and considering the suspicious areas of interest. Areas of restricted diffusion are bright on DWI using high B value and dark on ADC map indicating low ADC value. The visual assessment including the location of the affected group of lymph nodes and associated MR imaging findings e.g. pleural effusion.

Quantitative analysis:

• ADCs were calculated from the ADC maps, which were constructed from b = 0 and b = 1000 s/mm values. A region of interest (ROI) was drawn within the lesion on the ADC map. ROI positioned within areas of the most diffusion restriction on visual judgment, trying to avoid as much as possible obviously cystic or necrotic areas. Three ROIs were placed and the average of three measurement was recorded.

Statistical methods and data analysis

• Data analysis packages used were SPSS packages version 21 and Medcalc version 19.2. Qualitative data were presented by number and percentage while quantitative data were presented by average and range, Bar chart and box plot were used to display data accordingly. Statistical tests were done for qualitative data: Chi square test with Fischer exact for qualitative data and Mann–Whitney test for quantitative non-normally distributed data. Level of significance was considered if p equal to or below 0.05 ROC curve was used to detect validation of ADC of Hodgkin versus non-Hodgkin lymphomas. Youden index test was to detect cut odd point of ADC value, specificity, sensitivity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value as well as negative like hood ratio.

Results

This study involved 32 patients; 18 males and 14 females, age range 18–69 years (average of 34.375 years). All the patients diagnosed as lymphoma by histopathology. Cases were referred from clinical oncology department to radiology department for MRI chest with diffusion in the period from December 2018 to March 2020.

I. Non-treated group

• Cases were grouped according to their histopathological diagnosis into Hodgkin and non-Hodgkin lymphoma).

• Twelve cases diagnosed as Hodgkin while six cases diagnosed as non-Hodgkin lymphoma.

A. Hodgkin lymphoma

Six cases presented by discrete and partially amalgamated lymph nodes; while six cases presented by anterior mediastinal mass. There were affection of different groups of lymph nodes (Table 2).

Table 2 Summary of lymph nodes distribution in non-treated Hodgkin lymphoma

ADC range in non-treated Hodgkin lymphoma cases presented with lymph node presentation was 0.83 to 1.4 with ADC average 1.1072, while ADC range in cases presented with masses was 0.774 to 1.1 with average 0.939 (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1

A 65 year old male patient diagnosed as Hodgkin lymphoma. MRI was done before onset of therapy. a–d: a Axial T1 WI, b axial T2 WI, c axial DWI and d ADC map show amalgamated prevascular and paratracheal lymph nodes. They are isointense on T1 and T2 WI, hyperintense on DWI and hypointesne on ADC map denoting restricted diffusion with ADC mean value 1.165 × 10⁻³ mm²/s. e Coronal T2 WI and f Sagittal T2 WI showing multiple amalgamated mediastinal lymph nodes and right fissural pleural effusion

B. Non-Hodgkin lymphoma

One case presented by lymph nodes affection including internal mammary and supra-clavicular lymph nodes; while five cases presented by mediastinal mass (Table 3).

Table 3 Summary of masses distribution in non-treated non-Hodgkin lymphoma

ADC range in non-treated non-Hodgkin lymphoma cases presented with lymph node presentation was 0.476 to 0.548 with ADC average 0.512, while ADC range in cases presented with masses was 0.507 to 0.668 with average 0.5946 (Fig. 2).

Fig. 2

A 20 year old female patient diagnosed as Non-Hodgkin lymphoma. MRI was done before onset of therapy. a–d: a Axial T1 WI, b axial T2 WI, c axial DWI and d ADC map show anterior mediastinal mass isointense on T1 WI, heterogeneous hyperintense on T2 WI, hyperintense on DWI and hypointense on ADC map denoting restricted diffusion with ADC mean value 0.641 × 10⁻³ mm²/s

II. Treated group

• Cases were grouped according to their histopathological diagnosis into Hodgkin and non-Hodgkin lymphoma.

• Ten cases diagnosed as Hodgkin while four cases diagnosed as non-Hodgkin lymphoma.

A. Hodgkin lymphoma

Nine cases presented by discrete and partially amalgamated lymph nodes affecting different groups of lymph nodes; while one case presented by mediastinal mass pathologically proved to be thymic hyperplasia (ADC value = 2.6) (Fig. 3).

Fig. 3

A 30-year-old female diagnosed as Hodgkin lymphoma. MRI was done after starting receiving her chemotherapy sessions. a–d: a Axial T1 WI, b axial T2 WI, c axial DWI and d ADC map show anterior mediastinal mass lesion eliciting isointense signal in T1 and T2 WI, hyperintense signal in both DWI and ADC map with ADC value 2.566 × 10⁻³ mm²/s. The mass pathologically proved to be thymic hyperplasia

Six cases presented by restricted diffusion lymph nodes, 2 cases presented by facilitated diffusion lymph nodes and one case presented by restricted and facilitated diffusion lymph nodes (Fig. 4). The distribution of lymph nodes in treated Hodgkin lymphoma is demonstrated in Table 4.

Fig. 4

A 23-year-old female diagnosed as Hodgkin lymphoma. MRI was done after starting receiving her chemotherapy sessions. a–d: a Axial T1 WI, b axial T2 WI, c axial DWI and d ADC map show enlarged prevascular, paratracheal and internal mammary lymph nodes, which are isointense on T1 and T2 WI. In DWI, only the internal mammary lymph nodes showed restricted diffusion in the form of high signal in DWI and low signal in ADC map "arrow" with ADC value 1.08 × 10⁻³ mm²/s, whereas the rest of mediastinal lymph nodes showed no evidence of diffusion restriction denoting good response to therapy

Table 4 Summary of lymph nodes distribution in treated Hodgkin lymphoma

ADC range in treated Hodgkin lymphoma cases presented with lymph node presentation was 1.04 to 3.6 with ADC average 1.573) (Fig. 4).

B. Non-Hodgkin lymphoma

Two cases presented by lymph nodes affection; while two cases presented by mediastinal mass (Fig. 5). One case presented by anterior mediastinal mass with ADC value 1.29. Another case showed anterior mediastinal mass with MRI findings and ADC value (2.72) suggestive of thymic hyperplasia (Table 5).

Fig. 5

A 36 year old female patient diagnosed as Non-Hodgkin lymphoma. MRI was done after receiving her chemotherapy sessions. a–d: a Axial T1 WI, b axial T2 WI, c axial DWI and d ADC map show residual prevascular lymph node which is isointense on T1 and T2 WI, hyperintense on DWI and on ADC map with ADC value 2.8 × 10⁻³ mm²/s denoting facilitated diffusion and good response to therapy

Table 5 Summary of lymph nodes distribution in treated non-Hodgkin lymphoma

ADC range in treated non-Hodgkin lymphoma cases presented with lymph node presentation was 0.72 to 2.7 with ADC average 1.094) (Fig. 5).

Statistics

Relations of ADC difference in Hodgkin and Non Hodgkin lymphoma

There is statistic significant difference between ADC values in lymph nodes (p = 0.003) and mediastinal mass (p = 0.046) in Hodgkin and non-Hodgkin lymphomas (Table 6).

Table 6 Mann–Whitney Test

ADC cut off value to differentiate Hodgkin from non-Hodgkin lymphoma in lymph nodes is 0.72. Lymph node ADC value ≤ 0.72 is diagnostic for non-Hodgkin lymphoma while > 0.72 is diagnostic for Hodgkin lymphoma.

ADC cut off value to differentiate Hodgkin from non-Hodgkin lymphoma in mediastinal mass is 0.38. Mediastinal mass ADC value ≤ 0.38 is diagnostic for Hodgkin lymphoma while > 0.38 is diagnostic for non-Hodgkin lymphoma.

Relations of ADC difference in treated and untreated lymphoma

There is statistic significant difference between ADC values of mediastinal mass before and after chemotherapy (p = 0.002).

There is no statistical significant difference in results of chemotherapy in different lymph nodes groups (Fig. 6).

Fig. 6

Bar-and-Whisker plot: ADC mean values of NHL and HD

Discussion

Lymphoma represents one of the most common tumors in mediastinum approximately 10–15% of all masses [18, 19].

DWI is functional MR imaging technique with no need for special preparation, contrast injection or radiation exposure and allows the analysis of tissue characteristics based on the diffusivity of water molecules within tissues [20].

With the recent technology and advances in MR systems, diffusion weighted MRI (DWI MRI) of the chest is emerging as a promising fast technique that minimizes the effect of physiological motion artifacts that arise from respiration and cardiac movement [21].

The main purpose of this cross-sectional study was to assess the implementation of diffusion MRI in the algorithm of diagnosis of mediastinal lymphoma and assessment of post therapeutic response.

This study involved reviewing the DWI MRI finding results of 32 patients that were referred from the clinical oncology department for MRI assessment; all the patients were pathologically proved cases of lymphoma. Patients were grouped according to their histopathology and treatment status.

Out of 32 patients, 22 patients were diagnosed as Hodgkin lymphoma (68.75%) and 10 patients were diagnosed as non-Hodgkin lymphoma (31.25%).

Out of 32 patients, MRI was done to 18 patients before starting treatment; 12 patients were diagnosed as Hodgkin lymphoma (66.66%), and six patients were diagnosed as non-Hodgkin lymphoma (33.33%). ADC range was 0.476 to 1.4.

There is statistic significant difference between ADC values in LN (p = 0.003) and mediastinal masses (p = 0.046) in Hodgkin and non-Hodgkin lymphomas.

In agreement with Broncano et al. [22] and Çakmak et al. [23] who stated that, MRI DWI can be used as a reliable non-invasive technique that can differentiate between benign and malignant tumors including those of the mediastinum. This also consistent with Sabri et al. [21] and Abou Youssef et al. [24] who stated that the ADC values of malignant mediastinal lesions are significantly lower than those of benign lesions and determined cut-off ADC values to differentiate the two.

ADC range in non-treated Hodgkin lymphoma cases presented with lymph node presentation was 0.83 to 1.4 with ADC average 1.1072, while ADC range in cases presented with masses was 0.774 to 1.1 with average 0.939. The ADC range in non-treated non-Hodgkin lymphoma cases presented with lymph node presentation was 0.476 to 0.548 with ADC average 0.512, while ADC range in cases presented with masses was 0.507 to 0.668 with average 0.5946. ADC cut off value to differentiate Hodgkin from non-Hodgkin lymphoma in lymph nodes was 0.72 (p = 0.003), while ADC cut off value to differentiate Hodgkin from non-Hodgkin lymphoma in mediastinal mass was 0.38 (p = 0.046).

On other hand Razek et al. [25] and Sabri et al. [21], stated regarding the pathological subtypes of mediastinal lymphoma, that there were no statistically difference between the ADC average value of Hodgkin lymphoma and non-Hodgkin lymphoma in these studies but the ADC value of non-Hodgkin lymphoma was lower than Hodgkin lymphoma. These findings may be attributed to limited study on relatively small sample size.

In this study out of 18 patients who did not start treatment at time of study eleven (61.1%) cases presented by mediastinal masses and seven (38.9%) cases present by lymph nodes. On searching the literature, no attempts to differentiate between lymphoma presentation as masses or discrete lymph nodes, in particular were found.

All of the eleven cases with mediastinal masses had the epicenter of the mass in the anterior mediastinum; which agrees with Shahrazad et al. [26] who stated that mediastinal lymphoma usually occur in the anterior mediastinum.

In the non-treated group of Hodgkin cases presented by discrete and partially amalgamated lymph nodes, the distribution of lymph nodes was as follows: Enlarged para-tracheal lymph node were in five cases (19%), enlarged prevascular lymph nodes were in four cases (15%), enlarged para-aortic lymph nodes were in two cases (8%), enlarged sub-aortic lymph nodes were in three cases (11.5%), enlarged hilar lymph nodes were three cases (11.5%), enlarged subcarinal lymph nodes were in two cases(8%). Enlarged para-esophageal lymph nodes were in four cases (15%), enlarged cardio-phrenic was in one case (4%).enlarged supra clavicular lymph nodes was in one case (4%) and enlarged internal mammary lymph nodes was in one case (4%).

That is consistent with Mehrian et al. [27] study on patients with Hodgkin’s disease, enlarged lymph nodes were distributed mainly in the following zones: 4 (lower paratracheal; 89.2%), 3 (prevascular; 81.1%), 7 (subcarinal; 73.0%) and 2 (upper paratracheal; 70.2%). Zone nine (pulmonary ligament) and peri-diaphragmatic zones were rarely affected in either Hodgkin’s lymphoma.

Out of fourteen patients with MRI done after starting chemotherapy sessions; ten patients were diagnosed as Hodgkin lymphoma (71.428%), and four patients were diagnosed as non-Hodgkin lymphoma (28.571%). ADC range in treated Hodgkin lymphoma cases presented with residual lymph node presentation was 1.04 to 3.6 with ADC average 1.573. ADC range in treated non-Hodgkin lymphoma cases presented with lymph node presentation was 0.72 to 2.7 with ADC average 1.094, while ADC mean in one case presented with mass was 1.29.

In this study, there was statistically significant difference of ADC values in cases presented by masses before and after chemotherapy, while there was statistically insignificant difference of ADC values in case presented by lymph nodes before and after chemotherapy. These findings may be attributed to relatively small sample size.

This is agrees with Lin et al. [28], who stated that functional information provided by diffusion MRI are potentially helpful in assessment of response to treatment. Littooij et al. [29] stated that ADC measurements could be a valuable for the differentiation between viable and non-viable residual lesions.

De Paepe et al. [14] stated that DWI may be used as a response marker very early during treatment for lymphoma.

In two cases who had received chemotherapy, there was a residual anterior mediastinal mass lesion that was considered as residual lymphoma; however their ADC values were 2.6 and 2.7, suggesting benign nature rather than lymphoma residual. The possibility of thymic hyperplasia was considered and was proved by histopathology.

In agreement with Zhen et al. [30] who stated that thymus hyperplasia following chemotherapy can occur in both children and adults, but occurs most often in children, adolescents and young adults. It can occur in various types of tumors including lymphoma.

One case (7%) showed multiple residual lymph nodes; most of them showing facilitated diffusion denoting benign nature while only two showed restricted diffusion with ADC value reflecting malignancy. In agreement with Chowdhury et al. [31] and Spiekermann et al. [32] who stated that sarcoid like reactions have been described in association with many different types of malignancy.

In agreement with Sabri et al. [17] and Ibrahim et al. [33], who stated that DWI MRI can differentiate benign from malignant mediastinal masses and can differentiate lymphoma from sarcoidosis in the setting of mediastinal and hilar lymphadenopathy.

However as many studies, this study encompasses some limitations. First of them is the susceptibility artifacts despite the usage of phase array coil with cardiac gating and respiratory compensation techniques to improve image quality and speed. However, these artifacts were not severe enough to interfere with the diagnostic information gained by different MR sequences.

The second limitation is the relatively small number of cases, so we recommend further research on a larger population to confirm our results.

Conclusions

We concluded that DWI MRI is a promising functional technique in diagnosis of Hodgkin and non-Hodgkin lymphoma and assessment of response to treatment with significant statistic difference between ADC values of lymph nodes and mediastinal mass in Hodgkin and non-Hodgkin lymphomas.