Bilateral subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia with associated congenital anomalies: a case report and systematic review of cases
Egyptian Journal of Radiology and Nuclear Medicine volume 53, Article number: 197 (2022)
Cephalad renal ectopia is rare. Ectopic kidneys besides being prone to various pathologies are occasionally associated with other congenital abnormalities. To the best our knowledge, at the time of this writing, only ten cases of bilateral subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia had been reported.
Case presentation: We present a rare case of bilateral subdiaphragmatic ectopic kidneys incidentally discovered during evaluation of the abdominal pain. In addition, our patient had associated anomalies of the liver, spleen and mesocardia.
Recognition of this condition is important for accurate diagnosis, surgical and/or intervention planning, as well as identifying other associated anomalies.
Renal ectopia is not uncommon; it is estimated that renal ectopia is seen in 1:900 postmortem examinations and 1:3000 radiological imaging . However, cephalad renal ectopia is rare; for example, intrathoracic or subdiaphragmatic kidneys have estimated incidence of 1 in 22,000 . Importance of imaging is not only to detect renal ectopia, but also to evaluate frequently associated other genitourinary and non-genitourinary congenital abnormalities. There is higher incidence of urinary abnormalities like vesicoureteral reflux or hydronephrosis even in asymptomatic individuals. Ectopic kidneys may have reduced renal function and are often prone to infection, urolithiasis, trauma and malignancies [2,3,4,5]. This condition may also pose a challenge during surgery and interventional procedures [6, 7]. Cephalad ectopic kidneys in intrathoracic or subdiaphragmatic locations may mimic mass or simulate pathology on chest radiographs [8,9,10]. To the best our knowledge, at the time of this writing, there were only ten reported cases of bilateral subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia, but none were associated with mesocardia [11,12,13,14,15]. In this article, we present a case of incidentally discovered bilateral subdiaphragmatic ectopic kidneys with abnormal shape of the liver, and spleen as well as association of mesocardia.
A female in her thirties presented with ongoing episodic epigastric pain after eating and bloating for 10 years. An abdominal ultrasound was first performed which showed cholelithiasis, hepatosplenomegaly and incidental 1.5-cm hypoechoic lesion in the right lobe of liver. Left kidney was poorly visualized on sonography. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of abdomen with contrast was performed to characterize the liver lesion, which revealed that the lesion was slightly hyperintense on T2-weighted images, with hyperenhancement on arterial phase and isoenhancing to the rest of the liver parenchyma on portal venous phase. The imaging finding was felt benign, likely focal nodular hyperplasia (Fig. 1a, b). Cholelithiasis was again seen without evidence of cholecystitis. Liver was unusual in appearance with focally enlarged left lobe crossing the midline (Fig. 2a). Spleen was abnormally elongated craniocaudally measuring 19 cm (Fig. 2b). Incidental discovery of unusual cephalad location of bilateral kidneys in subdiaphragmatic location was observed (Fig. 2c). Ectopic kidneys showed normal rotation with renal hila projecting medially. No hydronephrosis or renal calculi were seen. Adrenal gland maintained its relationship with kidneys in anteromedial location. Inferior heart was partially visualized on abdominal MRI with cardiac apex in midline suggestive of mesocardia (Fig. 2d). Atrioventricular relation was maintained. Patient was recommended for echocardiogram for further evaluation of cardiac abnormality. Patient’s echocardiogram demonstrated no other cardiac abnormality except for mesocardia.
Kidneys develop from the metanephric blastema and ureteral bud starting at fifth week of gestation. The kidneys begin their development in the pelvic region and gradually ascend up to their final positions at the level of T12-L3 vertebra by the ninth week of gestation. This is followed by rotation of the axis resulting in medial position of the renal pelvis. Error in migration of ureteral bud to opposite side and induction of contralateral metanephric blastema results in crossed renal ectopia, while failure of ascent of ureteric bud and metanephric blastema after making contact leads to simple renal ectopia (Fig. 3). Multiple hypotheses for renal ectopia include ureteral bud maldevelopment, defective metanephric blastema, in utero vascular anomalies of kidney at different stages of development and genetic or teratogenic causes. While the etiology of cephalad renal ectopia is not definitive, the condition is thought to be caused by the premature accelerated ascent of the kidneys. If the ascent happens before the diaphragm closes (eight weeks of gestation), the result is intrathoracic kidney. But if the diaphragm closes earlier, then the ascent will result in subdiaphragmatic kidney [1, 16]. Postnatal cases of cephalad renal migration from infra-diaphragmatic location to both subdiaphragmatic and intrathoracic locations have been reported [17, 18]. Most of the reported cases of subdiaphragmatic kidneys had normal renal function [9, 12, 17, 19, 20]. The chances of infection and its complications are less often seen in cephalad renal ectopia compared to caudal renal ectopia due to good drainage in cephalad renal ectopia  (Table 1).
Subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia can be isolated or associated with congenital abnormalities. Literature review shows association of omphalocele with cephalad renal ectopia [12, 13]. Presence of omphalocele with herniation of liver and bowel loops probably facilitates cephalad position of the kidney. Also, eventration of diaphragm was observed in at least three cases of subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia, and again the eventration understandably would favor cephalad ascent of the kidneys [8, 22]. Our patient also had abnormal enlarged left lobe of liver, splenomegaly and mesocardia, a combination never seen before. Hepatosplenomegaly was also seen in reported case of bilateral subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia . Most cases of subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia were associated with omphalocele or eventration, conditions that would favor cephalad renal ectopia simply due to availability of space. Our patient also had history of omphalocele repair.
There are evidences to suggest coexistence of cardiac anomalies in patients with renal anomalies and vice versa . Cardiovascular anomalies in cases of subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia without omphalocele were patent ductus arteriosus and primary anterior inferior vena cava. In our case, mesocardia was seen, a condition in which baso-apical or longitudinal axis of the heart lies in the midsagittal plane without definite cardiac apex. Atrioventricular relation may be normal or altered in different types of mesocardia. Additionally, these patients may have various abdominothoracic situs as well as other congenital cardiac abnormalities. However, mesocardia with dextro bulboventricular cardiac looping in patients with situs solitus is a normal variant and not associated with other congenital cardiac abnormality, similar to our case. There may be other associated congenital abnormalities of spleen (asplenia, polysplenia and accessory spleen) in patients with mesocardia often determined by situs [27, 28]. In our case, no other abnormality of spleen was present except for splenomegaly.
Clinical presentation in renal ectopia may be non-specific, or patient may remain asymptomatic . Ectopic kidneys particularly intrathoracic and subdiaphragmatic kidneys can pose diagnostic challenges by mimicking mass particularly in chest radiographs [8,9,10]. Similarly, unusual location of kidneys can be a source of error in nuclear studies if one is not aware of possible cephalad renal ectopia [30, 31]. Having knowledge of this condition from prior imaging may be helpful in decreasing patient’s apprehension, preventing inaccurate diagnosis and need for further imaging work-up. Additionally, surgery and percutaneous intervention may be challenging in patients with these conditions which may have to be tailored based on imaging appearance of ectopic kidney [6, 32].
Bilateral subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia is one of the rarest forms of positional renal anomaly which may be isolated or associated with other congenital anomalies. It is important to be aware of abnormal locations of the kidneys and associated congenital anomalies which may pose not only diagnostic challenges but also help in decision making for surgery or intervention.
Availability of data and material
Magnetic resonance imaging
Mikuz G (2019) Ectopias of the kidney, urinary tract organs, and male genitalia. Pathologe 40(1):1–8
Arena F, Arena S, Paolata A, Campenni A, Zuccarello B, Romeo G (2007) Is a complete urological evaluation necessary in all newborns with asymptomatic renal ectopia? Int J Urol 14(6):491–495
Guarino N, Tadini B, Camardi P, Silvestro L, Lace R, Bianchi M (2004) The incidence of associated urological abnormalities in children with renal ectopia. J Urol 172(4):1757–1759
Muttarak M, Sriburi T (2012) Congenital renal anomalies detected in adulthood. Biomed Imaging Interv J 8(1):e7
Singer A, Simmons MZ, Maldjian PD (2008) Spectrum of congenital renal anomalies presenting in adulthood. Clin Imaging 32(3):183–191
Carrasco A, Castro R (2018) Right diaphragmatic eventration with an intrathoracic kidney: case report and review of the literature. Case Rep Surg 2018:1–7. https://doi.org/10.1155/2018/2631391
Joseph V (2006) The management of renal conditions in the perinatal period. Early Human Dev 82(5):313–324
Attia HMA (1999) Cephalad renal ectopia, duplication of pelvicalyceal system and patent ductus arteriosus in an adult female. Scand J Urol Nephrol 33(4):257–259
Louzir B, Beji M, Chtourou S, Fajraoui N, El-Mekki S, Jouini S et al (1999) Diagnosis of an opacity at the lung base: Intrathoracic kidney. Rev des Mal Respir 16(2):207–209
Hirayama I, Inokuchi R, Fukue M, Doi K (2019) Right subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia mimicking lung tumour. Thorax 74(7):721
Divjak E. Ectopic kidneys - subdiaphragmatic Radiopaedia.org2019 [cited 2022 16 Feb 2022]. Available from: https://radiopaedia.org/cases/68406
Parmar J, Mohan C, Vora M (2016) Cephalad-renal ectopia: Bilateral subdiaphragmatic kidneys in a patient of omphalocele with ventral hernia. Pediatr Urol Case Rep 3(3):63–67
Aliotta PJ, Seidel FG, Karp M, Greenfield SP (1987) Renal malposition in patients with omphalocele. J Urol 137(5):942–944
Peng X-X, Cheng S-A, Liang Q-L, Luo X-B, Hong X-C, Yuan G-L et al (2018) Bilateral thoracic kidneys combined with inferior vena cava located behind the anterior abdominal wall: a case report and review of literature. World J Clin Cases 6(13):666
Elshetry ASF (2021) Bilateral subdiaphragmatic kidneys with right-sided renal malrotation. Egypt J Radiol Nucl Med 52(1):1–4
Fleischner FG, Robins SA, Abrams M (1950) High renal ectopia and congenital diaphragmatic hernia. Radiology 55(1):24–26
Zolotas E, Krishnan RG (2016) Subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia: case report and review of the literature. Case Rep Nephrol 2016:1–3
Liddell RM, Rosenbaum DM, Blumhagen JD (1989) Delayed radiologic appearance of bilateral thoracic ectopic kidneys. AJR Am J Roentgenol 152(1):120–122
Kaur RP, Chawla D (1980) Right subdiaphragmatic kidney. Br J Radiol 53(632):809–810
Utanğaç MM, Kiliç S, Dağgülli M, Söylemez H (2015) Subdiyafragmatik ektopik böbrek: Olgu sunumu. Yeni Üroloji Dergisi 10(1):36–38
Natarajan A, Agrawal A, Purandare N, Shah S, Rangarajan V (2016) Rare case of thoracic kidney detected by renal scintigraphy. Indian J Nucl Med: IJNM: Off J Soc Nucl Med India 31(3):219
Spillane RJ, Prather GC (1952) Right diaphragmatic eventration with renal displacement: case report. J Urol 68(5):804–806
Strakosch C, Cooper R, Wiseman J, Hales I (1977) High ectopic kidney presenting as an abnormal liver-lung scan: case report. J Nucl Med 18(3):274-275. Retrieved from https://jnm.snmjournals.org/content/18/3/274
Kundu A, Goswami T (1995) Left subdiaphragmatic kidney: a case report. J Indian Med Assoc. Retrieved from https://pesquisa.bvsalud.org/portal/resource/pt/sea-98306
Muntaha Y (2004) Subdiaphragmatic ectopic kidney: a case report. Retrieved from https://pesquisa.bvsalud.org/portal/resource/pt/emr-66659
Greenwood RD, Rosenthal A, Nadas AS (1976) Cardiovascular malformations associated with congenital anomalies of the urinary system: observations in a series of 453 infants and children with urinary system malformations. Clin Pediatr 15(12):1101–1104
Lev M, Liberthson RR, Golden JG, Eckner FA, Arcilla R (1971) The pathologic anatomy of mesocardia. Am J Cardiol 28(4):428–435
Perloff JK (2011) The cardiac malpositions. Am J Cardiol 108(9):1352–1361
Cheng Y-Z, Lin H-J, Wu C-M (2009) Acute pyelonephritis of an ectopic kidney mimicking acute appendicitis: two unusual cases in an emergency department. Tzu Chi Med J 21(1):70–72
Hsieh H-J, Lue K-H (2008) The cephalad malposition of a kidney as a thoracic abnormality on Tc-99m MDP bone scintigraphy. Tzu Chi Med J 20(4):314–317
Demir SS, Aktaş GE, Polat A, Sarıkaya A (2017) Ectopic pelvic kidney mimicking sacral metastasis on post-therapy iodine-131 scan of a thyroid cancer patient. Mol Imaging Radionucl Ther 26(1):43
Matlaga BR, Kim SC, Watkins SL, Kuo RL, Munch LC, Lingeman JE (2006) Percutaneous nephrolithotomy for ectopic kidneys: over, around, or through. Urology 67(3):513–517
No funding was obtained for this study.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Non-identifiable images of the patient have been only used. Careful attention has been provided to make sure that no patient identifiable information is in the images provided.
Consent for publication
Informed consent from the patient has been obtained, and signed consent was provided by the patient.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Chaudhary, R.K., Larsen, M., Nepal, P. et al. Bilateral subdiaphragmatic renal ectopia with associated congenital anomalies: a case report and systematic review of cases. Egypt J Radiol Nucl Med 53, 197 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s43055-022-00887-w
- Ectopic kidney
- Cephalad renal ectopia
- Subdiaphragmatic kidney